War Causes

Does Religion Cause War? Part One

One often hears the lazy argument that “Religion” is responsible for Man’s wars, the implication being that if we got rid of religion, all would be peace and harmony. Presumably then, if all men abandoned the notion that they are spirits inhabiting a material body and conceived of themselves as mere animals fashioned by chance from mud our troubles would be over and we’d all be a lot happier. This is of course untrue and does not correspond with an observation of history, nor of present reality.

 It also displays a degree of fogginess about what one means by the word “religion” Religions vary considerably. There are pantheisms (the belief in many gods) monotheisms (the belief in one God who created all) and religions that worship no gods at all, such as Buddhism or modern Scientology.

At the far end of the spectrum there are even religions that do not conceive man to be an immortal soul even while life is considered to be nevertheless spiritual in essence.

 Some religions such as Christianity stress faith, while faith has no place at all in others -Scientology and Buddhism being cases in point.

 One should note too, while one is discussing paradigms based on Faith, that  materialism remains unable to produce conclusive evidence for its basic assumption. That spirituality does not exist is a matter of belief, not evidence. One can of course produce evidence that the material universe exists and one can establish and prove its laws but this is not proof that that the material universe is all there is. The assertion that the material universe is all there is is neither scientific nor logical and is actually a statement of faith.

 Alright, so this vague undefined variable known as “religion” or “faith” is responsible for Man’s wars. Is it true?

 Well, I can think of a few recent conflicts or humanitarian cataclysms whose driving force was anything but religious.

 Hitler’s massacre of ethnic minorities, for instance: religions were often the victim of Nazi psychosis but they were not responsible for it. In fact it is now a matter of record that the drive behind Nazi mass slaughter came from German Psychiatry, the arch-champion of the man-is-mud hypothesis.

 The drive behind the Russian revolution and the Stalinist slaughter that followed it was anything but religious, deriving again from the materialism of communism and psychiatry.

 Ditto the civil war and ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia. Ditto the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo, with materialistic psychiatry the hidden motivator again.

 The Chinese invasion of Korea in1950 and the Korean War that followed also had little or nothing to do with religious issues. One had materialistic communist China on the one hand and the largely atheistic commercial imperialism of western nations on the other.

 The US invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq were commerce-driven regardless of what justifications are concocted for it, while in the war in Vietnam, religion figured neither in the motivation nor rhetoric of either side.

 Not all war therefore is “caused” by “religion.” Religious groups are however often the victim or target of it but not exclusively and not always. There is no evidence that by “getting rid of religion” one would “get rid of war” any more than there is evidence that by outlawing atheism or abandoning commerce there would be peace on Earth.

Nor is there any evidence that an abandonment of spirituality would make society happier. On the contrary, our western society has become unhappier and more demoralized as it has become materialistic. You will probably find that the epidemic spread of drug abuse and crime on the one hand and the decline in man’s spirituality and even his sense of right and wrong follow commensurate curves. In the midst of material abundance, which theoretically should have made Man happier, we live out our days in an increasingly miserable Gomorrah of lost souls.

 Of course “religion” is a factor in the war in the Middle East and in justifications for their actions put forward by terrorist groups. And religion has been a factor in many a human conflict. It is true too that religious societies have not necessarily been happy ones either.

 In fact, a look at human history tells one that whether spiritual in outlook or materialistic in outlook, Man tends to have a hard time. From this one can conclude that humanity is still evolving its social forms and does not yet have all the answers. This is no reason to get apathetic about the whole thing and to abandon the effort to reason in favour of generalized, unworkable slogans. Indeed, we have every incentive to go on trying to get better at these things called society and civilization, if only through a sense of responsibility to our children who will inherit whatever dog’s breakfast we bequeath them.

 Getting better at managing human affairs requires that we knock off subscribing to broad, untrue, generalities such as “religion is the cause of war” or some such nonsense.

 Let’s look this thing over more carefully and see if we can get a bit more accurate about what exactly is getting us into trouble.

 Perhaps, if we do, we might as a species manage to comport ourselves with more dignity and kick the habit of following every psycho who seeks to persuade us to burn the skin off the children of people we have never met.

 I will continue this effort to apply reason to the matter of religion and war in the next essay in this series.

About the Author

I write these articles because I care and because I believe there are things you should know and have a right to know. I have also made available a number of free books, with more in the pipeline. Please visit my main blog at http://knowledge-is-freedom.blogspot.com for all my free articles and free books. On a broader and more general note there is also the HowDo Information Hub. Please check it out at http://www.howdohub.com.

Antonia Juhasz on “Structural Causes of War”

Causes and Consequences of the War of 1914 (1914) NEW $19.37

A View of the Causes and Consequences of English Wars: $24.55

The Myth of the Lost Cause and Civil War History $9.33

The Lost Cause; A New Southern History of the War of the Confederates 1867 $89.00

PRO WAR & PRO LIFE POLITICAL PINBACK PEACE CAUSE PIN $7.50

THE LOST CAUSE SOUTHERN HISTORY WAR OF CONFEDERATES EDWARD POLLARD PORTRAITS $18.95

On the Causes of War by Oxford University Press and Hidemi Suganami HARDBACK $69.99

The Root Causes of Sudan’s Civil Wars (African Issues) by Douglas Hamilton John $17.47

Mathew Brady’s Illustrated History of the Civil War 1861-65 and the Causes… $2.98

Causes of the Civil War: The Differences Between the No $47.42

What Causes War?: An Introduction to Theories of Inter $4.74

NEW – The Myth of the Lost Cause and Civil War History $19.02

Causes of International War (1920) NEW by G. Lowes Dick $29.65

The Causes of the War of Independence: Being the First $45.14

Astrology and the Causes of War NEW by Jamie MacPhail $61.60

THE CAUSES OF THE CIVIL WAR – KENNETH MILTON STAMPP (PAPERBACK) NEW $12.86

THE CAUSES OF WAR – DAVID SOBEK (PAPERBACK) NEW $30.58

The Causes and Issues of the Great War – Morris 1914 HC $14.37

THE CAUSES OF THE CIVIL WAR – PAUL CALORE (PAPERBACK) NEW $53.92

Nice 1914 Causes and Battles of The Colossal War in Europe Salseman’s Dummy Copy $31.23

World War II: Roots and Causes (Problems in European Civilization (DC Heath)) $64.82

The Myth of the Lost Cause and Civil War History by $7.99

22 old books EVENTS LEADING TO US CIVIL WAR causes secession confederate union $8.00

An Introduction to the Causes of War: Patterns of Inter $52.90

Book: HISTORY OF THE WAR Vol1-The Cause WW2 (King-Hall) $9.99

Civil War Book For Cause & Comrades 1997 McPherson $9.99

The Causes of the English Civil War (2nd Revised ed… $35.77

The Outbreak of World War I: Causes and Responsibilities Problems in 0669213594 $4.97

Causes and Consequences of the First World War (Causes & Consequences), Stewart $8.39

The History of the Confederate War: Its Causes and Its $28.04

The History of the Confederate War: Its Causes and Its $46.37

CAUSES & CONSEQUENCES OF THE VIETNAM WAR by Wright NEW $12.95

For Cause & Comrades Civil War FREE Shipping $8.00

Mathew Brady’s Illustrated History of the Civil War 1861-65 and the Causes… $7.50

NEW Cause and Probable Results of the Civil War in Amer $10.16

NEW The Franco-Prussian War and Its Hidden Causes (1914 $28.35

The Economic Causes of War NEW by Achille Loria $17.04

McGOVERN button PEACE CAUSE pin Anti Viet Nam War pinback 1972 Nixon Campaign $11.49

War Stories: The Causes and Consequences of Public … $86.20

FOR CAUSE & COMRADES Civil War J. McPherson 1997 1st HC $19.99

A View of the War, Its Causes and Results: Appeal to th $15.63

The Immediate Causes of the Great War NEW $13.88

8×10 World War II Photo: Rita Hayworth Helps War Cause $1.99

Statesment of the Lost Cause + Statesmen and Soldiers of the Civil War $11.99

Cause and Probable Results of the Civil War in America: $15.63

Causes of the War: An Examination Into the Causes of th $19.37

Arming The Glorious Cause; Weapons Of The 2nd War For Independence (Confederate) $35.95

The Second World War: v. 6: Causes and Background (… $324.91

CAUSES OF WAR – WILLIAM R. THOMPSON JACK S. LEVY (HARDCOVER) NEW $112.28

NEW The Franco-Prussian War and Its Hidden Causes – Oll $26.05

NEW Causes of the Afghan War; Being a Selection of Pape $20.25

NEW The Economic Causes of Modern War (Volume 6); A Stu $20.42

Cavalryman Of The Lost Cause Jeb Stuart Jeffry Wert 2008 Civil War HB DJ NM 1st $19.95

E.A.POLLARD-THE LOST CAUSE-FACSIMILE OF THE WAR OF THE CONFEDERATES-HARDCOVER $4.99

The Last Days of the Lost Cause – Civil War Story – Rare $75.00

Yankees Vs Rebels Bill Potter CASSETTE Civil War Causes $8.99

4×6 World War II Photo: Rita Hayworth Helps War Cause $2.75

Causes of the War of Independence 1922 Claude Van Tyne Rare Book U.S. History $45.00

The Franco-Prussian War and Its Hidden Causes (1912) NE $36.41

Lee and His Cause: Or the Why and the How of the War Be $20.91

World War II: Roots and Causes (1992, Paperback) $9.99

The Causes of the War of Independence: Being the First $34.22

The Lost Cause – The American Civil War: 1861 – 1865 War Board Game $45.95

Nash`s War Manual . Causes of WW1 etc. $19.43

The Iraq War: Causes And Consequences by $9.95

NEW The Occult Causes of the Present War – Lewis Spence $13.52

The Causes of the English Civil War NEW by Ann Hughes $132.89

The Causes of the English Civil War by Norah Carlin (1998, Paperback) $32.95

Causes of World War I (The Road to War: Causes of Conflict) ~ John Ziff $16.19

NEW The Causes of the English Civil War – Ann Hughes $106.45

NEW The Second Afghan War, 1878-80 V2: Its Causes, Its $21.90

The War in Europe Its Causes and Results NEW $40.52

For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War by James M. McPherson… $14.87

Prejudice, War and the Constitution: Causes and Consequ $8.95

For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War by James M. McPherson $26.16

NEW The Causes Of The War Of Independence – Van Tyne… $26.42

Winning a Cause: World War Stories (1919) NEW $28.97

NEW The Causes of the Civil War: Revised Edition – Stam $9.68

The Indian History of the Modoc War: And the Causes Tha $25.28

NEW Causes Of War – Sobek, David 9780745641980 $71.45

Claims as a Cause of the Mexican War (1914) NEW $18.55

Causes That Led to the War Between the States (1915) NE $18.64

1561 Plate block 10cent Contributor to the Cause Haym Salomon Financial Hero War $2.25

The American Civil War: A Concise History of Its Causes $35.68

A History of the Civil War, 1861-65, and the Causes Tha $36.07

The Deeper Causes of the War (1914) NEW by William Sand $15.63

TORRIJOS AIRPORT PANAMA 1989 Operation Just Cause WAR HISTORY 1992 ON GUARD CARD $1.99

SNIPERS PANAMA 1989-1990 Operation Just Cause WAR HISTORY 1992 ON GUARD CARD $1.99

DAYLIGHT ASSAULT PANAMA 1989 Operation Just Cause WAR HISTORY 1992 ON GUARD CARD $1.99

Causes, Course and Outcomes of World War Two by John Plowright (2007, Hardcover) $132.31

CAUSES & BATTLES of the COLOSSAL WAR in EUROPE HC 1914 $18.89

CONFEDERATE CIVIL WAR HISTORY E.A. POLLARD THE LOST CAUSE-STANDARD SOUTHERN HIST $10.49

Causes of the War: An Examination Into the Causes of th $30.38

Causes That Led to the War Between the States NEW $33.37

Causes of the Iraq War (The Road to War: Causes of Conflict), Jim Gallagher, Goo $3.85

1938 HORRORS OF WAR #159 MISTAKE IN IDENTITY CAUSES LOYALIST SLAUGHTER PSA 6.5 $65.00

1938 HORRORS OF WAR #195 CAPTURE OF SOVIET PILOT CAUSES JAP PROTEST PSA 6.5 $85.00

The Causes of War NEW by Robert Earl Swindler $23.67

The Causes of War NEW by Robert Earl Swindler $40.52

1997 Book FOR CAUSE AND COMRADES, WHY MEN FOUGHT IN THE CIVIL WAR $9.88

Star Wars Epiosode I 3 Piece Dinnerware Set – Podrace $11.00 Star wars dineware…

Bowmen Of Mons / Pearce Photo Mugs The Bowmen of Mons come to the aid of the British and cause havoc among their enemies ….

Emden Shells Madras Photo Mugs The German cruiser Emden bombards the oil tanks in the harbour of Madras, India, and causes substantial damage to shipping. But she, too, will be destroyed…….

Star Wars Trilogy [VHS] $11.21 The Star Wars trilogy had the rare distinction of becoming more than just a series of movies, but a cultural phenomenon, a life-defining event for its generation. On its surface, George Lucas’s original 1977 film is a rollicking and humorous space fantasy that owes debts to more influences than one can count on two hands, but filmgoers became entranced by its basic struggle of good vs. evil “a lon…

Star Wars Trilogy (Special Edition) [VHS] $7.98 The Star Wars trilogy had the rare distinction of becoming more than just a series of movies, but a cultural phenomenon, a life-defining event for its generation. On its surface, George Lucas’s original 1977 film is a rollicking and humorous space fantasy that owes debts to more influences than one can count on two hands, but filmgoers became entranced by its basic struggle of good vs. evil “a lon…